Available in a wide range of sizes and shapes, nail pullers are a handy tool to have for a variety of projects. Depending on the nail pullers you have, they can provide a lot of leverage, work well in tight areas. And pull-out nails that are headless or deeply embedded without marring the surface material. Here are a few tips and reviews to help you find the best nail pullers for your next renovation or construction projects.


Comparison Table – Nail Pullers

1
Estwing Pro Claw Nail Puller
Weight : 13.4 ounces

Size: 10.6″

Material: Steel

2
Crescent Nail Puller Pliers
Weight : 2.4 ounces

Size: 4″

Material: Forged Alloy

3
Crescent Nail Puller
Weight : 3.86 pounds

Size: 19″

Material: Forged Alloy

4
Estwing Nail Puller
Weight : 1.21 pounds

Size: 12″

Material: Steel

5
Dead On Tools Nail Puller
Weight : 8.8 ounces

Size: 10 5/8″

Material: Steel

6
Stiletto Clawbar Nail Puller
Weight : 8 ounces

Size: 12″

Material: Titanium

7
Faithfull Nail Puller
Weight : 4.63 pounds

Size: 24″

Material: Cast Iron

8
Spec Ops Nail Puller
Weight : 12.6 ounces

Size: 10″

Material: Steel

9
Bates Choice Nail Puller
Weight : 1.58 pounds

Size: 11″

Material: Iron

10
STANLEY FATMAX Pry Bar
Weight : 12.5 ounces

Size: 10″

Material: Steel

11
Vaughan & Bushnell Nail Puller
Weight : 2.44 pounds

Size: 14″

Material: Steel

12
Shark CORP Nail Puller
Weight : 13.6 ounces

Size: 11″

Material: Steel


Top 12 Best Nail Puller Reviews

 

Estwing Pro Claw Nail Puller – Best Overall Nail Puller

Estwing Pro Claw Nail Puller – Best Overall Nail Puller

Featuring forged steel construction, the Estwing Pro Claw Nail Puller is equipped with a cushion grip that will not slip and a high leverage design. This 10.6-inch pry bar also includes a precision thin claw and a design that lets you remove headless nails.

Durable

Forged into one piece, the Estwing Pro Claw Nail Puller is a durable and long-lasting striking tool. Featuring a rounded head, this design provides increased leverage and additional torque. Plus, the cushioned grip will not cause your hand to slip, so you have a comfortable and strong hold under any type of condition.

Precise

Capable of removing headless nails, the Estwing Pro Claw Nail Puller has a claw design that lets you easily remove a headless nail with very little damage to the wood. Equipped with a super-thin claw, this nail puller offers precision and the ability to get to those hard-to-reach places.

Check Price

Pros
  • The grips have a no-slip design
  • It provides a strong and comfortable hold
  • You can use it on headless nails
Cons
  • It’s too short for some applications
  • The mouth isn’t wide enough

Crescent Nail Puller – Best Flexible Nail Puller

Crescent Nail Puller – Best Flexible Nail Puller

The Crescent Nail Puller is equipped with professional grips that easily wipe clean. These nail pullers are a great choice for removing pin nails, damaged fasteners, brads, headed nails, coaxial or wire staples, floor staples, and finishing nails. With their dual handles, these nail pullers are easy and fast to roll, grip, and extract stapes or nails.

Dual-Handle

Equipped with a forged steel head, the Crescent Nail Pullers also feature handles that can withstand the harsh conditions of a job site. The dual handle makes it quick and easy to grip, roll, and remove nails or staples, and the forged steel head and handles stand up to the rigors of any job site.

Functional

Featuring a black-oxide finish, these pullers are corrosion resistant and include a roll bar that lets you pull out nails with a low-effort and smooth action. These functional pliers feature teeth that are designed with an optimal grip to pull out a variety of fasteners. With unlimited flexibility, the Crescent Nail Pullers allow you to easily remove nails no matter how large or small they are or if the head is removed or damaged.

Check Price

Pros
  • This is an easy to use tool
  • It is strong and durable
  • It has a lot of flexibility with its uses
Cons
  • There is a 1/8 inch gap at the tip of the pliers, which makes it almost impossible to grab small staples and nails close to the wood
  • This tool is heavy, and it is hard to use for long periods of time

Crescent 19″ Nail Puller – Best Utility Nail Puller

Crescent Nail Puller – Best Utility Nail Puller

The 19-inch Crescent Nail Puller is a forged alloy nail pull that both homeowners and professionals will love. Featuring strength and utility, these pullers have a box-joint design that includes a tempered, hardened jaw that can withstand harsh job site conditions.

Durable

The 19-inch Crescent Nail Puller comes with either a short or long jaw. Both options feature a black enamel finish that provides extra durability. This tool works well hard to grip and flush nails and is a handy tool to have for renovation and remodeling projects.

Check Price

Pros
  • These pullers are very versatile and work in a lot of different applications
  • They are very durable and can handle the job site
  • These pullers are great for both professionals and DIYers
Cons
  • It’s on the expensive side
  • It’s so wobbly it is hard to get the teeth on the nail

Estwing Nail Puller – Best Precision Nail Puller

Estwing Nail Puller – Best Precision Nail Puller

Measuring 12-inches, the Estwing Nail Puller is a double-ended pry bar that includes both a wedge and straight claw end. Featuring yellow and blue paint, the Estwing Nail Puller features polished ends and is very durable and strong.

Precise and Sharp

Capable to pull a wide range of fasteners, these sharp and precise nail pullers easily remove headless or embedded nails with very little wood damage. The head design has a rounded shape that offers increased leverage while the precision thin claw design allows you to get to those hard-to-reach nails.

Lightweight

Ideal for renovation and construction, the Estwing Nail Pullers are lightweight but strong thanks to their one-piece forged design. Long-lasting and durable, these pullers offer more leverage and added torque.

Professional Design

The Estwing Nail Puller is designed for professionals and serious DIYers making it perfect for tradesmen, roofers, framers, demo crews, woodworkers, and carpenters. This is a great tool for use on baseboard, molding, and door and window trim. Allowing you to work in tight or small areas, the precision claw on the Estwing Nail Puller makes headless nail extractions easy while also preventing damage to wood.

Check Price

Pros
  • This is a great tool for professionals
  • It won’t damage wood but can take out headless nails
  • You get a lot of torque and leverage with these pullers
Cons
  • The tips aren’t very sharp
  • The nail pulling side is as thick as that of a hammer

Dead On Tools Nail Puller – Most Affordable Nail Puller

Dead On Tools Nail Puller – Most Affordable Nail Puller

Created for professional use, the Dead On Tools Nail puller features a classic nail puller style and measures 10 5/8-inches long. This is a high-quality product with a narrow body that was designed for a skilled craftsman.

Efficient

Allowing you to work efficiently, the Dead On Tool is the perfect size when it comes to a nail puller. One side of the nail puller features a circular saw wrench making it the ideal tool to pull up nails. It is also the best size when you need to remove nails in a tight space.

Check Price

Pros
  • This is an affordable and durable tool
  • It works well in small spaces
  • It includes a circular saw wrench
Cons
  • It’s smaller than some users expected
  • It chips easily

Stiletto Clawbar Nail Puller – Best Titanium Nail Puller

Stiletto Clawbar Nail Puller – Best Titanium Nail Puller

Weighing only 8 1/2 ounces, this solid titanium bar features an open truss design. The Stiletto Clawbar Nail Puller features a recessed area around the head of the nail that lets the claws slid underneath, which reduces the potential for chipping the wood. This tool is five times stronger than a steel bar, and also has ten times less recoil shock.

Lightweight

Weighing less than other nail pullers, the Stiletto Clawbar Nail Puller includes two sets of claw tips as well as a strike plate that is longer lasting than steel that also won’t tear, crack, roll, or mushroom. Offering very strong prying power, the Stiletto ClawBar Nail Puller is comfortable to grip and lessens user fatigue. Delivering performance and consistent accuracy, these nail pullers are a great addition to your job site.

Check Price

Pros
  • It’s strong and accurate
  • This is a lightweight and durable nail puller
  • It’s comfortable to use and won’t make your hand tired
Cons
  • They aren’t as strong as some users expected
  • They chip easily

Faithfull Nail Puller – Best Leverage Nail Puller

Faithfull Nail Puller – Best Leverage Nail Puller

Measuring 24 inches, the Faithfull Nail Puller has enough length to provide a good amount of leverage. This is a great tool to remove nails from almost any material as well as take apart wood structures, open wooden crates, and lift floorboards.

Strength

This specialized tool is capable of removing nail heads that have recessed under the surface level. The Faithfull Nail Puller is equipped with a malleable cast iron slide handle that includes a drop-forged, hinged gripping jaw that is fixed to a box joint for added strength. The handle on the Faithfull Nail Puller is levered forward to use the base heel as the leverage pint and to keep the jaw tight when removing a nail.

Check Price

Pros
  • The jaw will stay tight when removing nails
  • It has a good length to provide the leverage you need
  • This tool works on pretty much all materials
Cons
  • It’s heavy-duty and takes a lot of effort to work with
  • Some users had issues with parts falling off

Spec Ops Nail Puller – Most Comfortable Nail Puller

Spec Ops Nail Puller – Most Comfortable Nail Puller

Made from high-carbon steel, the Spec Ops Nail Pullers is a good choice when removing headless nails, small nails, and embedded nails. Equipped with two nail pullers, these pullers feature precision-honed claws that provide versatility and causing minimal damage.

Lightweight

Featuring an advanced and lightweight skeleton design, the Spec Ops Nail Puller is 20 percent lighter than its competitors making it more comfortable to use. With its sniper control design, this nail puller offers precision when pulling out sharp nails while the two strike zones were created for accuracy and fast nail extraction. These pullers are compatible with SRS Retention Lanyards for additional safety.

Check Price

Pros
  • These pullers are accurate and quick to use
  • They are very lightweight and comfortable to work with
  • They cause very little damage to wood
Cons
  • It’s smaller than some users expected
  • It’s hard to use on nails

Bates Choice Nail Puller – Most Versatile Nail Puller

Bates Choice Nail Puller – Most Versatile Nail Puller

This multi-tool is versatile and offers long-lasting performance. The Bates Nail Puller is made with high carbon steel that prevents rusting and also includes a soft plastic-coated grip. Use these nail pullers to pull out staples, panel pins, and nails easily and effortlessly.

Versatile

Measuring 11-inches, the Bates Nail Puller can even remove nails with a damaged head and works on nails and staples stuck in the wood. This tool is ideal for handymen, carpenters, and construction workers.

Convenient

You can also use this tool to take out nails from molding without damaging the trim pieces, plus you can use them to rip out old carpet or when installing wood floors. The Bates Nail Puller is handy to have when you need to fix a framing mistake and not damage the piece of wood.

Check Price

Pros
  • Easy and effortless to use
  • You can use them on nails with damaged heads
  • They won’t damage the wood when pulling nails out of it
Cons
  • It is hard to pry the jaws open
  • It’s not easy to use in corners or tight spaces

STANLEY FATMAX Pry Bar – Best Ergonomic Nail Puller

STANLEY FATMAX Pry Bar – Best Ergonomic Nail Puller

This ten-inch set of pullers gives you a good amount of leverage for prying and nail pulling. The Stanley Fatmax Pry Bar is extremely durable and strong and features an ergonomic grip for comfort.

Safe and Durable

The Pry Bar is heat-treated for durability and tempered for safety. It features a flat striking face that allows you to drive the claw deeply under embedded nails. Plus, the beveled claws and the polished flat surface provides precise penetration.

Ergonomic and Strong

Incredibly durable and strong, the Pry Bar is made out of forged, high-carbon spring steel and is equipped with an ergonomic grip that provides comfort and protection from harsh temperatures.

Check Price

Pros
  • It has a lifetime warranty
  • This is the perfect tool for prying and nail pulling
  • It is heat-treated for increased durability
Cons
  • It needs to be longer to give you better leverage
  • The soft metal it’s made out of doesn’t last long

Vaughan & Bushnell Dalluge Da Bar – Most Reliable Nail Puller

Vaughan & Bushnell Dalluge Da Bar – Most Reliable Nail Puller

Ideal for removing trim work and molding, the Vaughan & Bushnell Dalluge Da Bar is lightweight and thin but tempered forged for strength. Featuring rounded body edges, this puller is easy and comfortable to grip.

Solid and Reliable

The flat claws on the Da Bar Pullers will slip under nails easily and limit any damage to surfaces made of wood while the rocker head offers better leverage. This is a reliable, solid, and sturdy tool that will last you years.

Compact and Strong

Compact enough that you can carry the Da Bar Pullers in your tool bag or pocket, these pullers are still strong enough to use on heavy-duty projects. Measuring 14-inches long, this tool provides just the right amount of leverage so you can pull out really long nails without issue.

Comfortable

This is a comfortable pair of pullers to use that reduces the pressure on your hand as you pull out an embedded nail while increasing your comfort. With its slender design, the Da Bar Pullers includes a chrome finish that is chip and corrosion-resistant.

Check Price

Pros
  • They provide great leverage
  • These nail pullers are resistant to chipping and corrosion
  • They have a slender design that works in tight spaces
Cons
  • They are thick and damage wood as you pull out nails
  • Metal is a bit soft allowing the tip to bend

Shark CORP Nail Puller – Most Accurate Nail Puller

Shark CORP Nail Puller – Most Accurate Nail Puller

Made with a hardened steel alloy, the Shark CORP Nail Puller easily pulls out rusted, embedded, and headless nails. These durable pullers prevent bending or chipping. Measuring 11-inches long, this tool is large enough to give you the leverage you need without having to exert extra effort.

Accurate and Precise

Using an advanced tempering method, the Shark CORP Nail Puller uses drop-forged construction that provides that added durability you want. Capable of functioning accurately and precisely in a harsh environment, these pullers will last you a long time.

More Torque

Giving you the ability to pull our medium and small-sized nails without issue, the head of this nail puller has a rounded design to provide more torque while reducing the amount of work you need to do to pull out those tough nails.

Compact

The claws on the Shark CORP Nail Puller are also sharp, so you can reach headless nails easily. This compact nail remover easily fits in your pocket or tool bag without taking up a lot of space.

Check Price

Pros
  • These pullers are compact and lightweight
  • They work well for small jobs
  • These pullers work with nails well
Cons
  • The tool’s pointed ends aren’t machined or as sharp as they should be
  • They do not have a rubber grip making them hard to hold onto

Best Nail Puller Buyers guide

Features to Look for in a Nail Puller

Power

Power is one of the most important factors when determining how well the tool will be able to remove embedded nails and dig out nails without heads. If you have a longer handle on your nail puller, that means you will have to apply less force to get the nail out. A lot of this depends on the leverage or power that your nail puller has and how well it applies to the application you are working with. So, make sure you choose the right nail puller for the project you have in mind.

The Profile

If your nail puller has a larger profile, it can be hard to use it between the nail and the surface. A narrower profile is actually preferable since the nail puller can slide easily in between the surface and the nail, especially in a small space. With this type of design, you will get a faster nail removal process that is able to preserve the surface’s structure from any damage.

Work Surface

With a traditional nail puller, you have a higher likelihood of leaving a scratch on a wood surface. With a powered model, you have a slender and smooth profile that could be perfect for precise nail removal. You also don’t want the finished wood surface you are working with to end up defaced from your nail-pulling process, so it’s important to take your time and to choose wisely.

Weight

A lightweight nail puller is more comfortable to carry and use for long periods of time. Remember that the more lightweight the too is, the easier it will be to work all day without losing your energy or feeling weighed down. You also want to ensure that the lightweight design won’t compromise the efficiency and strength of the product.

Compact

It’s important to consider the area where you will be working to decide if you need a large or small nail puller. If you are working in an area with enough clearance, you will need something smaller and that will be able to fit into tight spaces.

Handle

Look for a nail puller that has a substantial and strong metal handle that uses a rubber cover. This will allow you to use it for long periods of time without having it stick to your hand. This nail puller will also have a stronger grip and make it easy and safe for you to apply the required force that you need to pull out a nail that is embedded.


FAQs

What Kind of Area Are You Working In?

Before you buy a nail puller, consider the type of space you will be working in. Working in a shed is different than remodeling your bathroom. One area is a cramped and small area where you will need a shorter tool in comparison to projects that will require more precision work.

It can be an added benefit to having an added tool on the other end of the nail puller offering you even more options for your projects. A nail puller can help you remove nails easily and quickly, as long as you have the right type of tool for where you are working.

Are Claws or Jaws Better?

There are two categories for nail pullers. One will pry out the nail with a set of parallel teeth called claws, or two parallel jaws that you can close and open while using the handles to pull out the nail. Each has their own set of advantages and disadvantages and have particular situations that they work best in.

Claws

Perfect for working in a tight area, claws help you get into those close corners. Small nail removers that have a nice, angled head allow you to easily pull nails out. This type of tool can require strength to use and may be hard to operate with one hand if you don’t have enough upper body strength.

Jaws

This type of nail puller is a good choice when you work in a large and open area. are ideal if you are working in a large open area. You won’t need as much power to operate these nail pullers since they work using the physics of angles and levers. These nail pullers are the best option if you don’t have the upper body strength and are pulling a lot of nails out of a pallet. Nail pullers with jaws can pretty much grip any type of nail and make it easily smooth to remove nails without a head. These nail pullers are pretty hard to operate with just one hand and they aren’t as comfortable to use as the claws for long periods of times.


Summary/Conclusion

Depending on the type of job and your own unique requirements, the best type of nail puller can vary. Make sure you choose a reliable brand and a high-quality nail puller with the features that work best for the applications you have planned. Having the right type of nail puller will not only save you time and money, but it will make your renovation go a lot smoother.


John Billiou

John Billiou

LOCATION: Visalia, California

OCCUPATION: President

John Billiou assumed operations of the family business in 1989 with a “big appetite” for success.

Based in Central California, Billiou's Has been serving the Parts Needs of Lawn & Garden Dealers Across the Western United States for 70 Years.

Today, the company distributes new equipment and parts in 13 Western states and John said their No. 1 customers are cities and counties.

Billiou’s provides field support through their call center, field sales force, and an extensive website.

Billiou’s team strives to longstanding value to the customer and readers by making reliable and solid buying recommendations.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *